Goatmilk
Member
What do you think about the overworld of BOTW and TOTK overall @Goatmilk? Like if you had to tell the developers directly in a meeting face to face? I just ask because I'm assuming you have a lot of critiques for it
I never said The Wind Waker had the best overworld, the best overworld in the series definitely belongs to Ocarina of Time or Majora's Mask. It's honestly a coin toss for me but both are nearly perfection in my view as a fan of TLoZ
The problem with TWW is that a strong portion of the exploration had to come from imagination when traversing the map. I still love TWW's overworld and sailing the Great Sea and all that, but it was the first Zelda game to kind of 'miss' the bullseye not only with its overworld, but other aspects as well. TWW took big risks, those risks paid off too, yet they also came with some letdowns in the eyes of the fans
BOTW was incredibly refreshing at the time. The sense of exploration was unparalleled to me. But being so big it made the horseback exploration downplayed for fast travel and tower flying. So a lot of the space has trouble capturing you because you're just rushing through. But it's there if you want it...so your experience isn't dictated by anything but your own idea of where to go which was amazing.
The problem is that there isn't any locations that are locked off by enemies (TOTK has the dragons or whatever they're called) which makes you worried to go to certain places.
TWW didn't really have much to see, and it teased a lot of things that I'm sure their short dev time didn't allow them to explore. But TWW had so many banger moments that BOTW didn't have becuase of its open endedness. Nothing is as iconic as going into the Temple of Time and restoring color.
I wish that BOTW shrunk it down to like half the size and more tightly integrated dungeons like ALTTP. More of a puzzle box. Having said that, I really enjoyed how open it was...so I don't know. TOTK just never connected becuase it's the same overworld and the depths are a slog, the sky is very copy and paste. Nothing about TOTK besides the insane physics system says 'this took 6 years to make'. I was expecting so much more.