3liteDragon

Roving Reporter
Starfield-E3-2018.jpg

Starfield is real. Image Credit: GamesBeat
Microsoft has no plans to release Bethesda’s upcoming space role-playing adventure Starfield on Sony’s competing PlayStation 5 console. That shouldn’t surprise too many people after Xbox boss Phil Spencer said in March that Microsoft acquired Bethesda to add exclusives to Xbox Game Pass. But I’ve separately confirmed that this situation applies to Starfield through sources familiar with the decision.

But some people keep asking about Starfield on PS5 because they don’t have insight into Microsoft’s reasoning. While Sony or Nintendo would certainly keep new acquisitions locked to their platforms, Xbox has a history of playing nice. Minecraft, for example, is still getting full support on PlayStation and Nintendo platforms. Microsoft even released the new Minecraft Dungeons game on PS5 and Switch. So why wouldn’t Microsoft do the same with Bethesda’s games?


The difference is that Minecraft is a platform unto itself with millions of active players and in-game transactions. And it’s platform like that thrives when it’s available everywhere. I’ve asked Xbox for a statement, and I’ll update this story if the company decides to comment.

Starfield is most valuable to Microsoft as a means to grow Xbox Game Pass

Where Minecraft can exist as its own service, Starfield is about growing the Game Pass service. And even if Bethesda has ambitions to make massive, connected live-service games, it’s unlikely that anything will turn into the next Minecraft. So an effort like a blockbuster game release from the team that made The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim is best if Microsoft treats it as an investment into a larger service.

“With Game Pass now the center of the Xbox ecosystem, it is becoming more important for Microsoft to invest in exclusive content and IP that increases the value of the service and leads to new user acquisitions,” Niko Partners analyst Daniel Ahmad explained on Twitter.

Ahmad nails it.

Microsoft likely did investigate what its financials would look like if it made Bethesda games exclusive or not. In the end, it chose exclusivity. And yes, that means it will miss out on money from sales on PlayStation 5. But the point is that Microsoft doesn’t see that as losing money — it sees that as built in marketing for Game Pass. And then it also expects to offset many of those costs by building a deeper relationship with more players who then go on to play and buy even more games on Xbox platforms.

So yes, Starfield is exclusive. And I would predict that Xbox would make this call for The Elder Scrolls VI and beyond.
 

MildWolverine

Member
Platforms
  1. PC
  2. Xbox
  3. PlayStation
  4. Nintendo
This article simply states what platform exclusivity is.

I wouldn't expect Ghost of Tsushima to be on Xbox ever either.

Yes Bethesda is a new acquisition and the game was probably in development for all platforms at some point. But this is how things work.

This isn't really news.

I wouldn't be shocked if it does eventually come to PS5 after some period of time, games do leave GamePass all the time.
 
Last edited:

Arkam

I'm the Captain Now
 
If I was MS, I would make it exclusive too. It makes all the sense in the world.... unless it relies on multiplayer and your CCU count is too low (like we saw last gen in some instances). But it does feel a bit like whiplash going from Phil saying "exclusives are bad!!!" to this so quickly. Really shows how momentum, changes things. Hope the younger folks pay attention... cuz this happens a lot.
 

Arc

Banned
Member
I’m not assuming anything. Microsoft was pretty uncommitted when talking about Bethesda exclusives. To me, that kind of hesitancy points at a multiplatform strategy, but we’ll see if Grubb staking his reputation turns out correct.
 

Cato

Member
Good I guess. MS needs some high profile exclusives.

Lets pray they do update that god-damn outdated engine too.
(I will play it when gamepass comes to the ps5. :) )
 

Grinchy

Permission to suckle
 
Good I guess. MS needs some high profile exclusives.

Lets pray they do update that god-damn outdated engine too.
(I will play it when gamepass comes to the ps5. :) )
It seems like an expensive venture to fully port the game to PS5 just for whatever PS5 users decide to try out game pass. And they wouldn't just be doing this game, they'd have to fully port every Xbox exclusive that's on game pass to PS5 for that to work. It's one reason I don't quite understand the assumption that it could work.
 

Dr Bass

Member
It seems like an expensive venture to fully port the game to PS5 just for whatever PS5 users decide to try out game pass. And they wouldn't just be doing this game, they'd have to fully port every Xbox exclusive that's on game pass to PS5 for that to work. It's one reason I don't quite understand the assumption that it could work.

They could do it if an XCloud app was allowed onto PS5. But come on, if you want to play it and don't want to do it on PC just buy an Xbox! There will be more than Starfield worth playing on it ...

I can't figure out how to edit a reply into a previous post on here ...
 

Grinchy

Permission to suckle
 
They could do it if an XCloud app was allowed onto PS5. But come on, if you want to play it and don't want to do it on PC just buy an Xbox! There will be more than Starfield worth playing on it ...

I can't figure out how to edit a reply into a previous post on here ...
I just can't honestly see a mass influx of users paying $10/month on top of any other PS-related fees/subscriptions to stream games. People don't even pay for PS Now lol.

This idea that every platform can have gamepass because xcloud works flawlessly is extremely untested. Game streaming kinda blows.
 

HeresJohnny

Member
 
Makes perfect sense to me. They paid a lot of money for Bethesda and it's dumb IMO to put a game you paid a lot of money for on another platform. Unless you're Sony -- then it makes perfect sense.